Showing posts with label Sexism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Sexism. Show all posts

06 January 2016

She Wasn't Having It (foul pranks and management shrugs)



Yesterday, I Tweeted a story related by my partner after he spoke with a woman he works with. As I've received permission to share, I am posting it here with a few additional details. I am keeping all names anonymous so neither my partner (“Joe”) nor his colleague (“Donna”) encounter any backlash.

Joe and Donna work at a major international financial company; it’s one of the leading financial institutions in the world. Their particular office, a smallish one, is located in a thriving, corporate-centered city. It’s also a city where 30% of the population lives in poverty. Many employees commute daily from NYC, Washington DC, Philadelphia, and surrounding areas. Joe, a 54 year old white man, is one of those commuters; Donna, a 61 year old African-American woman, does not. They both arrive at the office quite early in the morning, so they tend to talk quite a bit.

Joe is one of the company’s Web workers; Donna is one of the company’s custodial workers—in fact, she’s the only full-time daily custodial presence. Yesterday morning, Joe saw her for the first time in a while, and he asked how she was. Donna responded, “Disgusted.” 

A few weeks before Christmas, Donna had a routine day taking care of the building’s various offices until she tended to the programmers' office floor. She vacuumed the corridor, and then she entered the men’s room. There, she saw a napkin in a urinal, along with a note reading, in caps, CLEAN THIS UP. Donna lifted the napkin, which covered a pile of feces. She was, naturally, shocked that someone had shit in the urinal and laid a napkin over it, but that abrupt, demeaning, order for her to clear it away was too much. She spun on her heel and left the room.*

Donna went to her superior to complain, but he brushed it off and said she should ignore it. Refusing this response, Donna then went to her superior's supervisor, who also said she should ignore it. Following that, Donna went to Human Resources. HR also suggested she ignore it. To Donna, the implication appeared to be that one or two of the programmers, the majority of whom are young men, were merely playing prankster, so she should not take it seriously. "Boys will be boys," etc. (I completely understand this impression because who among us wouldn’t think it would be funny to prank a middle-aged Black woman by shitting in a urinal and ordering her to clean it up?)

Donna fetched her coat and bag, and she left. She walked straight off the job. Donna refused to return to work for several days, during which time she phoned her union representative. As you might expect (for whatever reason), the union didn’t dismiss her complaints; they contacted HR directly. Donna’s union told the company that, should she return to work, in no way would she, nor the company, tolerate ill behavior by other employees.

The company assented to the union’s terms, but the precise conditions of Donna’s return are vague (I’m hoping a raise is involved. She makes $9.00 an hour. Nine dollars an hour to put up with this type of thing). Donna did return to her job, but she remains disgusted and disheartened. She is looking for work elsewhere.

Donna is impressive. Her actions, and sense of worth, are stellar, and her union’s actions are commendable, the company’s most certainly isn’t. Several levels of management shrugged off the incident, which signals approval of the “prank.” A prank where one or more well-paid, young, male commuters felt comfortable directing Donna to clean up their filth.

*in my original series of Tweets, I wrote that “she did her job,” i.e., cleaned the filth, before going to management. I later corrected that as my partner told me “Hell, no. She left it there. Who knows who cleaned it up.”

22 March 2013

"Militants" Life Magazine, 1913

On March 3rd, 1913, people from around the nation collected in Washington DC for the Woman Suffrage Parade. At least five thousand people joined together to "march in a spirit of protest against the present political organization of society, from which women are excluded" (LOC). Many participants concluded the march successfully; many were taken to hospital because of onlookers' violent behavior:
Women were jeered, tripped, grabbed, shoved, and many heard “indecent epithets” and “barnyard conversation.” Instead of protecting the parade, the police “seemed to enjoy all the ribald jokes and laughter and part participated in them.” One policeman explained that they should stay at home where they belonged. The men in the procession heard shouts of “Henpecko” and “Where are your skirts?” As one witness explained, “There was a sort of spirit of levity connected with the crowd. They did not regard the affair very seriously.” (LOC)
The cartoon below, from Life Magazine's issue of 3/27/1913, just weeks after parade, reflects the march's onlookers' perspective (click for larger view/to read captions):






















Aside: as an undergrad, I found this cartoon in an oversize sourcebook of feminism's history. If I'd have known then that one day I'd share a Xerox of this document with the world...anyways, I've been packing this around for nearly 30 years. Enjoy.


29 January 2009

GOP Seeping Sexism

Posting and running: two points from today’s news:

1. President Obama today signs into law the Lilly Ledbetter Fair Pay Act, which “focuses on pay and other workplace discrimination against women” (AP). Republicans have long opposed this legislation, in part because it would “benefit trial lawyers.” Last week, several Republicans (all four female GOP Senators and Arlen Specter) chose to cross the aisle and vote with the Democratic majority in support of the bill (The Hill). The majority of Republicans continued to oppose the Ledbetter Act.

2. In an exchange on Hardball, Dick Armey tells Salon’s editor-in-chief Joan Walsh:

“I am so damn glad that you could never be my wife, ‘cause I surely wouldn't have to listen to that prattle from you every day” (qtd. in Calderone).

Take from this what you will.


18 November 2008

"The Year of the Woman"? Not So Much. . . .

Amanda Fortini at New York Magazine has considered how, rather than breaking misogynist stereotypes, Hillary Clinton and Sarah Palin (and the media's treatment of them) might have reinforced sexist perceptions of women. Read "The Bitch and the Ditz" here.

10 September 2008

Lipstick Variations, or, Sandbox Politics

Welcome to “lippygate.”

What’s the difference between these two statements?

From The Chicago Tribune:

McCain criticized Democratic contenders for offering what he called costly universal health care proposals that require too much government regulation. While he said he had not studied Democratic candidate Hillary Clinton's health-care plan, he said it was "eerily reminiscent" of the failed plan she offered as first lady in the early 1990s.

"I think they put some lipstick on a pig, but it's still a pig," he said of her proposal.

From The Christian Science Monitor:

“John McCain says he’s about change too, and so I guess his whole angle is, ‘Watch out, George Bush – except for economic policy, health care policy, tax policy, education policy, foreign policy, and Karl Rove-style politics – we’re really gonna shake things up in Washington.”

“That’s not change, [. . .] That’s just calling something the same thing something different. You know you can put lipstick on a pig, but it’s still a pig.”

Apparently, although the former was directed specifically at a woman’s proposal and the latter to a man’s general political appeal, the latter is sexist. You see, according to the McCain campaign, Obama wasn’t directing the remark at McCain’s “plan for change.” He was directing it at Sarah Palin. Despite Governor Palin's dismissal of sexism in politics this year(she referred to Hillary Clinton’s "running as victim" and “whining”), her team isn't afraid to cry foul. Ex-Massachussetts Governor Jane Swift, the head of Governor Palin’s “truth squad,” issued the following statement:

“Ultimately, I think the American people will realize that calling a very prominent female governor of one of our states a pig is not exactly what we want to see when we supposedly are going to have this great debate that is the politics of hope,” Swift said.
The McCain campaign is clearly hoping that people see Obama’s line as an allusion to Palin’s speech at the Republican National Convention. I can see their point, But was it a "smear"? The “lipstick on a pig” phrase is one of those tiresome, empty phrases politicians refuse to release, and, honestly, it’s simply puzzling that one year ago, the phrase was McCai's cliché; this year, it’s Obama's sexist attack. Unsurprisingly, the Obama camp picked up on this immediately:

“Enough is enough,” said Obama campaign official Anita Dunn. “The McCain campaign’s attack tonight is a pathetic attempt to play the gender card about the use of a common analogy — the same analogy that Senator McCain himself used about Senator Hillary Rodham Clinton’s health care plan just last year.”

The desperation in how people are seeking and grasping at perceived attacks has just become silly now. Consider the complaints about Biden’s and McCain’s “sexist” jokes about their wives, or claims that the McCain’s “celebrity” ad was essentially “racist.” Both campaigns, and their more ardent, unthinking supporters, run the risk of appearing childish and petulant, and, as a result, turning the public off. Maybe this isn't such a good thing now that Dr. Ron Paul has sent out a general call for people to vote third party this year.

The last word goes to Huck: “It’s an old expression, and I’m going to have to cut Obama some slack on that one."

Trust Huck to add some common sense.

Added: To Swampland: thank you! In Mark Silva's view:

Everyone is playing with half a deck if they think the American voters are looking for a whining war of alleged offenses against the race of the Democratic nominee for president, the gender of the Republican nominee for vice president or the patriotism of either parties' candidates. The only card that plays out in a debate of one-liners like this is the Joker.

And PolitiFact gives the McCain/Palin campaign a full on "pants on fire" for this nonsense.


Aside: In case you've read reports that neglect to include Obama's followup to the "lipstick on a pig reference": when he mentioned her name and the audience began catcalling, he shushed them. He repeated the call to lay off of her family and her religion, and he expressed admiration for her accomplishments. Read this AP report for his comments.

Palin "Takes Back the Joke"

Note how Palin “appropriated” an old line of sexist jokes:


Question:What’s the difference between a Pro[-]choice feminist and a guerrilla?
Answer:Lipstick. (Perhaps the author meant “gorilla,” otherwise the punchline fails).

Question: What’s the difference between a Rotweiler and a feminist?
Answer: Lipstick. .

Question: What's the difference between a woman with PMS and a pit bull?
Answer: Lipstick

Question: What’s the difference between a hockey mom and a pitbull?
Answer: Lipstick (Sarah Palin)


01 September 2008

Rumor Central: Palin Is Not a Grandmother (Yet)

Woosh....Conspiracy theorists have settled on Sarah Palin, her daughter Bristol, and her infant son, Trig, who was born on 18 April.

Over the Labor Day weekend (how appropriate!) bloggers, such as this one, began issuing claims that Sarah Palin's son is, in actuality, her 17 year old daughter's child. You see, Palin masked the "shame" of the infant's illegitimacy by pretending the child was her own.

Bosh.

Much of the rumor is based on assumptions and questionable evidence; in just one example, a photograph showing the daughter's "baby bump" is produced to "prove" that she was pregnant. Problem: apparently, the photo was taken two years ago. Moreover, consider that the older the mother is, the greater the chance that her baby will be born with Down Syndrome.

To top it all off, Governor Palin has just announced that her daughter is currently five months pregnant (and intends to marry the man who impregnated her). If the young woman is this far along, then we can take this as confirmation that she couldn't be Trig's "real" mum: it's highly unlikely that a woman can get re-impregnated the very same month that she gives birth.

I do wonder if the McCain folks knew about this pregnancy before they settled on Palin? It might be that Bristol has just told her parents the news, but is it easy to hide a pregnancy that is five month along? But then, it doesn't really matter. The daughter will "do right" in Conservative eyes by both marrying the father and keeping the baby.

Some people may justify this rush of rumor-mongering on the public's lack of knowledge about Palin, just as they blame the wealth of gossip about Obama on the fact that "people don't know about him," but this is a nonsense excuse. It's simply because they are in the public eye, and because they are vying for powerful positions, and powerful people attract conspiracy theories like nothing else (expect, perhaps, flying saucers).

Update 12/29: NOW Sarah Palin is a grandmother. Per Politico:
Bristol Palin, 18, gave birth on Sunday and named the boy Tripp Easton Mitchell Johnston, the magazine reported. He came into the world weighing 7 pounds and 4 ounces.

31 August 2008

Underestimating Palin's Potential

Joe Trippi is right: Democrats dismiss Sarah Palin at their own peril. See his post, "Don’t LOL. Palin Pick Is About Taking On Washington — Not About Gender," and note his argument well. Trippi predicts that McCain, having acquired a VP with a solidly reformist background, will employ rule number one from Karl Rove's playbook: turn your opponent's greatest strength into a weakness. In this case, Trippi asserts, McCain and Palin will zero in on Obama's role as "agent of change" and recast him as part and parcel of the political establishment:
The McCain/Palin duo will challenge Barack Obama’s claim of “a new kind of politics” and chastise Obama and Democratic Vice Presidential Nominee, Joe Biden, for their “silence” in taking on corruption in their own party in Illinois, Delaware and Washington, DC.
Think about it; the McCain camp didn't decide on Palin solely to pander to the distaff vote (and assuming as much underestimates women voters as well as the McCain campaign. Neither are stupid). Palin's record of cleaning up corruption, and her status as Washington "outsider," help reinvigorate McCain's "maverick" image; thus strengthened, he'll be equipped to go after Obama at full blast. And he will.

Democrats: don't laugh. Don't brush her off. Ignore her at your own risk.

Aside: Having said that, do read Maureen Dowd's column on Palin, "Vice in Go Go Boots." Fab.

Added: Bruce Reed at Slate,
"Why Democrats needn't rush to trash Sarah Palin."

Update: Is Palin as straight-up and golden as she seems, and is she so terribly anti-earmark as she suggests? Perhaps not. See USA Today, The Anchorage Daily News, and The LA Times, . If nothing else, her history seems mixed at best.

30 August 2008

Sarah Palin Gives Hillary Shout Out, Gets Booed by GOP Crowd

Well, she tried.

John McCain's VP choice, Sarah Palin, spoke in Pennsylvania today, and, as in Friday's Dayton speech, she graciously mentioned Hillary Rodham Clinton as a groundbreaker. Yesterday they applauded. Today? Not so much:
But in contrast with the mild reception that greeted her comments at the Ohio event, when Palin praised Clinton here for showing “determination and grace in her presidential campaign,” the Alaska governor was met with a noisy mix of boos, groans and grumbles around the minor league ballpark where the “Road to the Convention Rally” was held.
Ouch. How are PUMAs going to take this? They're going to go and hook up with the party that tormented Senator Clinton for nearly twenty years? The crowd's reaction to Palin's mentioning Hillary testifies to the Republican base's objection to the Clintons--you know, the reason why Rush Limbaugh kickstarted Operation Chaos (a ploy, by the way, also pushed by Laura Ingraham).

The whole idea that Republicans were planning on voting for Democratic nominee Hillary Clinton, the woman they vilified for well over a decade, was questionable, and this reaction to her name suggests that the GOP idea of Hillary as arch-villainess remains entrenched--at least, in Pennsylvania.

(Aside: I thought Pennsylvania was "Hillary country")

Update: Palin has excised references to Hillary Clinton and Geraldine Ferrarro from her stump speech.

Happy now PUMAs?

29 August 2008

Sarah Palin Completes the GOP Ticket

After "Pawlenty" of rumors (sorry), we have John McCain's choice, and it's grand news: today Senator McCain will announce that Sarah Palin, Alaska governor and GOP "outsider," is his VP choice.

Although this comes nearly thirty years after Geraldine Ferrarro, the first woman to run as VP for a major political party, taken in conjunction with Hillary Clinton's groundbreaking run, surely this indicates progress in women's position in American culture. the county may not, as yet, be prepared for a woman to take over the Oval Office directly (e.g, as head of a ticket), but we're getting there. We're getting there.
Congratulations, Ms. Palin!

(and a very happy birthday to John McCain!)

Aside: According to NPR, McCain and Palin will greet a crowd of 15,000 in Dayton: the largest ever crowd for Senator McCain. Maybe they'll greet him with a resounding chorus of "Happy Birthday to You."

25 August 2008

Joe's Joke, John's Jest: Chill

Some people are a bit peeved about Joe Biden’s “joke” about his wife Jill on Saturday. Okay, folks, how is this:

"Ladies and gentlemen, my wife Jill, who you'll meet soon, is drop dead gorgeous," said Biden.

"She also has her doctorate degree, which is a problem," he added. "

Worse than this:

“I told her with a little luck that [Cindy McCain] could be the only woman to serve as First Lady and Miss Buffalo Chip,” Mr. McCain told the crowd, as his wife waved to them.

According to ESPN, the Miss Buffalo Chip competition “is essentially a topless beauty pageant. And occasionally bottomless, too.”

Yes, men make jokes about their wives, and sometimes those jokes are inappropriate. Pelosi’s right on this one, people. Get a grip. There are real things to get bent out of shape over.

15 June 2008

Rich: Clinton's Women Angry Enough to Back McCain?

This morning’s New York Times featured a well-observed piece by Frank Rich, “Angry Clinton Women (heart) McCain?”

In pointing out the irony of irate feminists’ alleged support of John McCain out of spite, Rich references out some of Senator McCain’s documented sexist behavior (I shy away from using the term “misogynist, which seems to have lost some of its bearings), such as a tasteless joke he made in at a 1998 Republican fundraiser: “Why is Chelsea Clinton so ugly? Because her father is Janet Reno,” and how he dealt with the question “how do we beat the bitch [Clinton]” by laughing awkwardly (Rich doesn’t mention McCain reportedly referring to Cindy McCain as a “cunt” and a “trollop” in front of others).

Now, I don’t believe that McCain is a walking, talking, woman-hating machine, I do think that his brain isn’t always engaged (not because of age, but because John McCain doesn’t always seem to consider what he’s going to say before he says it). What is more striking about these incidents is that women who have been crying out in anger and frustration at Senator Clinton’s treatment have (allegedly) declared their support for someone who has enabled and enacted that treatment. So what accounts for those legions of Clinton women for McCain that we keep hearing about? Rich claims that the media, and the public, perception on these feminists relies on prejudiced views of women:

the notion that all female Clinton supporters became “angry white women” once their candidate lost — to the hysterical extreme where even lifelong Democrats would desert their own party en masse — is itself a sexist stereotype. That’s why some of the same talking heads and Republican operatives who gleefully insulted Mrs. Clinton are now peddling this fable on such flimsy anecdotal evidence.

Indeed. The media has played for months on the image of the irrational, hysterical woman who, being emotionally attached to her cause (here, to see a woman achieve the highest office in the USA), would cut off her nose to spite her face. Didn’t this stereotype prevent women from obtaining political power for centuries? Don’t we celebrate figures such as Elizabeth I, Margaret Thatcher, Indira Ghandi, and Queen Victoria because of their stoic mien? They proved that women are as capable of reasoned, rather than primarily emotive, thinking and behavior as men. (1)

It is true that some women are truly furious and disheartened by Senator Clinton’s suspension of her campaign (we’ve seen them on YouTube), and some websites such as Hillary is 44, No Quarter, and Taylor Marsh (2) feature disenchanted posters who are stridently anti-Obama. However, there is little evidence to support the belief that McCain’s campaign is benefitting from an influx of Hillary fans. (3)

As Rich argues, this fracturing of the party by sex is only part of a larger media, and political, drama: “[t]he larger plot has it that the Democratic Party is hopelessly divided,” when, in reality, “[i]t’s the Democrats who are largely united and the Republicans who are at one another’s throats.” Dissension lingers amongst Republicans. The Senator’s funds are limited, in part because Bush’s supporters have not contributed to McCain’s war chest. Fourteen Conservative congressmen and women haven’t endorsed McCain. Ron Paul’s supporters aren’t straying from their man, and many noted Republicans have endorsed Senator Obama. Among them are Francis Fukuyama (a neocon architect and author of The End of History) and Douglas Kmiec, a conservative legal scholar (Kmiec also supported the liberal legal scholar Erwin Chermerinsky when U C Irvine withdrew an offer of deanship for political reasons). For other examples, please see the Wikipedia entry for “Obama Republicans.”

So how long will this portrayal of the distaff Democratic defection play out? I shouldn’t think too much longer. The more that polls show Obama leading McCain, the less we’ll here about the masses of disappointed females. Eventually it will seep through to the media that pollsters are calling people who don’t fit the latte sipping, Volvo driving, African-American, university educated, elitist, moonbat, liberal male demographic. Perhaps it might take a bit of time, but as we move closer to the Denver convention, and then to the general election, the media will recognize that maybe--just maybe--there really is a longing for optimism, unity, and change that's floating about in the zeitgeist, and that the majority of Americans, male and female, are willing to take a chance on the young junior senator from Illinois.

Notes

1) Keep in mind that Elizabeth I, Margaret Thatcher, and Queen Vctoria were not “masculine,” indeed, they retained their woman-ness. But they didn’t allow emotion to overwhelm key decisions. Being “rational” does not equate with being “masculine.”

2) A strong support of Senator Clinton’s campaign, Marsh has announced her support for Obama.

3) There are questions about the posters on these sites. For one, there are claims that many are, in fact, Republicans devoted to continue Operation Chaos. Another is that the number of Clinton followers out there is artificially inflated because the majority of these people post commentary to several fervently pro-Clinton blogs, sometimes under different nyms.

09 June 2008

So, You're Saying That There Was Sexism, But No Racism?

The following series of links is the rough material from which I plan to draw for an upcoming post. As I've not got to writing said post, and I’m always eager to share links, here you go…

In a complaint about Hillary Clinton’s treatment during the campaign, a commentator at a popular democratic blog left the following:

Now wrap your mind around this: If Obama had been called, God forbid, the n word or jokes made about watermelons, or shine my shoes, etc. there would have been an AVALANCHE of protest from everywhere!

Don't tell me about vile things said about Obama supporters when it was OUR CANDIDATE that was insulted over and over and over again.

Think we're angry? You have no idea.

Alrighty then. Let's play. Did we hear about all of these?

“Racist Incidents Give Some Obama Campaigners Pause”

Curious George t shirt and Obama

SP: on racist attacks on Obama

Curious George and the Rush Limbaugh Show

GOP Congressman Apologizes for Calling Obama 'Boy'

“Obama and the Bigots”

And to be fair, we can’t forget the Obama Campaign “race baiting” memo:
Obama Camp Memo on Clinton and Race Baiting

Several videos at You Tube, some featuring watermelons, some the KKK, currently exist. I’ll post links shortly. Oh, and some of those videos also employ overt misogyny. One, in fact, targets “fat white women” who support Obama.

And, of course, the miles of text devoted to racist cliches and dog-whistling on blogs worldwide. Or do they not count?

Also, is a diehard Hillary campaigner (and pro-HRC sockpuppeter who constantly defames Obama on sites such as Hillaryis44) the same woman who posed as a 67 year old black woman to infiltrate the online chat room of Sally Heming’s descendents in order to prevent those descendents from being admitted to the all-white Monticello Association? You might recall that Sally Hemings was Thomas Jefferson’s slave. One of her descendents has been DNA tested, which confirmed the descendent’s relationship with Jefferson. The woman in question aided the fight to deny validity to Heming's descendent's claims.

More on the sockpuppetry later, perhaps (someone else is working on it [see comments], and I'd hate to step on toes when s/he has done so much research), but here are two articles, both of which name the lady, to peruse.
http://www.realclearpolitics.com/articles/2008/02/the_democrats_options.html
http://topics.nytimes.com/top/reference/timestopics/people/j/thomas_jefferson/index.html?offset=45&s=newest


UPDATE: The women I alluded to above is named Paulie Abeles (also known as Paula Abeles), and she was mentioned today in Ben Smith's blog at Politico. Apparently she contacted the site to complain about her pro-Clinton group's treatment by Politico, and Mr. Smith did a little research: he discusses the Monticello Association episode. Do read his article.

UPDATE II
: The Atlantic's Matthew Yglesias has a brief write up on the Abeles affair. The Comments following his piece are quite, well, telling. Abeles herself contributes a plea that this "smear" is unjustified as it's common practice to assume a pseudonym on the internet (let's be pedantic: a pseudonym is the adoption of a different name, not an invented identity--say, that of a 67 year old African-American woman with emphysema when one is a relatively young, upper-middle class, white woman).

Note: Abeles posted the exact same comment at Politico. She includes her email address in both; methinks someone is hoping for media contact.

Added: Someone posted this at Politico. (comment by "Amazon Grace," 6/16, 08:59). I've left the bold in place.
Paulie is a DIE-HARD all right, a die hard racist. Teh goodgle found this on Amazon, a review of a Thomas Jefferson-Sally Hemings book. I bolded the more, er, calm and civilized portions.
3 stars - Politically Incorrect September 15, 2000 By "spabeles" For anyone who has followed the Jefferson-Hemings story this is an interesting book. However, it glosses over much of the historical evidence, and seems to suggest that anyone who questions the conclusion that Jefferson fathered Hemings children is a racist. Media sound bites and Lanier to the contrary, the DNA evidence for Jefferson's paternity is very shaky and Lanier neglects to mention that the descendents sic of Madison Hemings (of whom he is one) refused to be tested at all (although he does mention that the DNA testing eliminated the 150 year old claims of the Woodsons) Regardless, Lanier believes that ALL the families should be accepted by the Jefferson family to order to support racial harmony (which seems a little ridiculous since there are always people who try to claim descent from more illustrious forbears). Most of all, you are left with great sadness that the Hemings descendents are so desperate to be related to Jefferson it has become the focus of their lives, and even when their claims are proven impossible (as with the Woodson families), they still cling to a belief that they are descended from a great WHITE man (which is pretty sad). Whether Jefferson never acknowledged the Hemings children or treated them differently than any of the other house slaves because he was a really bad guy, OR because they were not in fact his children is a question that will remain (at least for me) until more sophisticated DNA analysis can link paternity not to one of 27 Jefferson males, but to Thomas Jefferson himself.

"They still cling to a belief that they are descended from a great WHITE man (which is pretty sad)," a statement that is pretty darned revealing.

31 May 2008

Hillary Clinton Has Never Been the Underdog.

Here’s a reminder of how things were before Clinton’s campaign lost the plot—because that is precisely what they did. They overspent and underplanned because they assumed Clinton would walk right into the nomination. And it worked until February, 2008: excepting for a tie in April 2007, Clinton led Obama in all national polls until early February.

Remember that Iowa’s caucus was held on 3 January, 2008. Note how Clinton’s support fell off following Super Tuesday, and remember that Clinton’s plan didn’t extend beyond Super Tuesday.

Democratic Presidential Nomination (from Real Clear Politics)

Polling Data

Poll

Date

Sample

Obama

Clinton

Spread

CBS News/NY Times

01/30 - 02/02

491 LV

41

41

Tie

USA Today/Gallup

01/30 - 02/02

985 LV

44

45

Clinton +1.0

Pew Research

01/30 - 02/02

596 RV

38

46

Clinton +8.0

ABC/Wash Post

01/30 - 02/01

LV

43

47

Clinton +4.0

Rasmussen

01/29 - 02/01

900 LV

37

45

Clinton +8.0

FOX News

01/30 - 01/31

377 LV

37

47

Clinton +10.0

NBC/WSJ

01/20 - 01/22

Adults

32

47

Clinton +15.0

LA Times/Bloomberg

01/18 - 01/22

532 LV

33

42

Clinton +9.0

Rasmussen

01/16 - 01/19

900 LV

34

38

Clinton +4.0

AP-Ipsos

01/15 - 01/17

453 RV

33

40

Clinton +7.0

CNN

01/14 - 01/17

448 RV

33

42

Clinton +9.0

Reuters/Zogby

01/11 - 01/13

459 LV

38

39

Clinton +1.0

USA Today/Gallup

01/11 - 01/13

1021 LV

33

45

Clinton +12.0

Pew Research

01/09 - 01/13

621 RV

31

46

Clinton +15.0

Hotline/FD

01/10 - 01/12

380 LV

35

38

Clinton +3.0

ABC/Wash Post

01/09 - 01/12

423 LV

37

42

Clinton +5.0

CBS News/NY Times

01/09 - 01/12

508 LV

27

42

Clinton +15.0

CNN

01/09 - 01/10

443 RV

36

49

Clinton +13.0

USA Today/Gallup

01/04 - 01/06

499 A

33

33

Tie

Rasmussen

01/03 - 01/06

900 LV

29

33

Clinton +4.0

Pew Research

12/19 - 12/30

556 RV

26

46

Clinton +20.0

FOX News

12/18 - 12/19

RV

20

49

Clinton +29.0

Cook/RT Strategies

12/15 - 12/17

RV

26

38

Clinton +12.0

NBC/WSJ

12/14 - 12/17

Adults

23

45

Clinton +22.0

USA Today/Gallup

12/14 - 12/16

513 A

27

45

Clinton +18.0

Rasmussen

12/13 - 12/16

750 LV

27

40

Clinton +13.0

Reuters/Zogby

12/12 - 12/14

436 LV

32

40

Clinton +8.0

Hotline/FD

12/10 - 12/14

336 LV

30

35

Clinton +5.0

Battleground

12/09 - 12/12

LV

23

47

Clinton +24.0

ARG

12/09 - 12/12

600 LV

22

41

Clinton +19.0

CNN

12/06 - 12/09

RV

30

40

Clinton +10.0

CBS News/NY Times

12/05 - 12/09

417 LV

27

44

Clinton +17.0

AP-Ipsos

12/03 - 12/05

469 RV

23

45

Clinton +22.0

LA Times/Bloomberg

11/30 - 12/03

529 LV

21

45

Clinton +24.0

USA Today/Gallup

11/30 - 12/02

494 A

24

39

Clinton +15.0

Rasmussen

11/28 - 12/01

750 LV

24

37

Clinton +13.0

AP-Pew

11/20 - 11/26

467 LV

22

48

Clinton +26.0

Rasmussen

11/15 - 11/18

750 LV

24

41

Clinton +17.0

Reuters/Zogby

11/14 - 11/17

545 LV

27

38

Clinton +11.0

FOX News

11/13 - 11/14

397 RV

23

44

Clinton +21.0

Gallup

11/11 - 11/14

485 A

21

48

Clinton +27.0

American Res. Group

11/09 - 11/12

600 LV

21

46

Clinton +25.0

Cook/RT Strategies

11/08 - 11/11

376 RV

22

39

Clinton +17.0

AP-Ipsos

11/05 - 11/07

474 RV

22

45

Clinton +23.0

NBC/WSJ

11/01 - 11/05

Adults

25

47

Clinton +22.0

USA Today/Gallup

11/02 - 11/04

508 RV

22

50

Clinton +28.0

CNN

11/02 - 11/04

467 RV

25

44

Clinton +19.0

Rasmussen

11/01 - 11/04

750 LV

22

41

Clinton +19.0

Newsweek

10/31 - 11/01

433 RV

24

43

Clinton +19.0

Marist

10/29 - 11/01

385 RV

17

48

Clinton +31.0

ABC/Wash Post

10/29 - 11/01

598 A

26

49

Clinton +23.0

Quinnipiac

10/23 - 10/29

742 RV

21

47

Clinton +26.0

Zogby

10/24 - 10/27

527 LV

24

38

Clinton +14.0

FOX News

10/23 - 10/24

329 RV

25

42

Clinton +17.0

Pew Research

10/17 - 10/23

837 RV

24

45

Clinton +21.0

LA Times/Bloomberg

10/19 - 10/22

469 LV

17

48

Clinton +31.0

Rasmussen

10/18 - 10/21

750 LV

22

49

Clinton +27.0

CBS News*

10/12 - 10/16

456 RV

23

51

Clinton +28.0

CNN

10/12 - 10/14

485 RV

21

51

Clinton +30.0

USA Today/Gallup

10/12 - 10/14

500 A

21

50

Clinton +29.0

Reuters/Zogby

10/10 - 10/14

426 LV

25

46

Clinton +21.0

American Res. Group

10/09 - 10/12

600 LV

20

45

Clinton +25.0

FOX News

10/09 - 10/10

377 LV

18

50

Clinton +32.0

Gallup

10/04 - 10/07

488 A

26

47

Clinton +21.0

Rasmussen

10/04 - 10/07

750 LV

26

42

Clinton +16.0

AP-Ipsos

10/01 - 10/03

482 A

25

46

Clinton +21.0

ABC News/Wash Post

09/27 - 09/30

592 A

20

53

Clinton +33.0

AP-Ipsos

09/21 - 09/25

631 A

26

40

Clinton +14.0

Rasmussen

09/20 - 09/23

750 LV

28

40

Clinton +12.0

Gallup

09/14 - 09/16

531 A

25

47

Clinton +22.0

CBS News*

09/14 - 09/16

Adults

22

43

Clinton +21.0

Reuters/Zogby

09/13 - 09/16

LV

21

35

Clinton +14.0

Pew Research

09/12 - 09/16

568 RV

25

42

Clinton +17.0

Cook/RT Strategies

09/13 - 09/15

405 RV

23

36

Clinton +13.0

FOX News

09/11 - 09/12

396 RV

24

43

Clinton +19.0

AP-Ipsos

09/10 - 09/12

482 RV

23

43

Clinton +20.0

American Res. Group

09/09 - 09/12

600 LV

21

39

Clinton +18.0

NBC/WSJ

09/07 - 09/10

Adults

23

44

Clinton +21.0

CNN

09/07 - 09/09

Adults

23

46

Clinton +23.0

NYT/CBS News*

09/04 - 09/09

Adults

26

44

Clinton +18.0

USA Today/Gallup

09/07 - 09/08

500 LV

24

45

Clinton +21.0

Rasmussen

09/05 - 09/08

750 LV

22

43

Clinton +21.0

ABC News/Wash Post

09/04 - 09/07

Adults

27

41

Clinton +14.0

Rasmussen

08/23 - 08/26

750 LV

21

40

Clinton +19.0

FOX News

08/21 - 08/22

335 LV

23

35

Clinton +12.0

Gallup

08/13 - 08/16

Adults

21

42

Clinton +21.0

Quinnipiac

08/07 - 08/13

717 LV

21

36

Clinton +15.0

American Res. Group

08/09 - 08/12

600 LV

21

36

Clinton +15.0

Rasmussen

08/09 - 08/12

750 LV

23

43

Clinton +20.0

CBS News*

08/08 - 08/12

492 LV

25

45

Clinton +20.0

CNN

08/06 - 08/07

RV

21

40

Clinton +19.0

USA Today/Gallup

08/03 - 08/05

490 A

19

42

Clinton +23.0

Cook/RT Strategies

08/02 - 08/05

376 RV

21

39

Clinton +18.0

Newsweek

08/01 - 08/01

422 RV

23

44

Clinton +21.0

NBC/WSJ

07/27 - 07/30

481 A

22

43

Clinton +21.0

Rasmussen

07/26 - 07/29

750 LV

24

40

Clinton +16.0

Pew Research

07/25 - 07/29

623 RV

21

40

Clinton +19.0

Hotline/FD

07/19 - 07/22

RV

30

39

Clinton +9.0

ABC News/Wash Post

07/18 - 07/21

Adults

28

39

Clinton +11.0

FOX News

07/17 - 07/18

RV

23

39

Clinton +16.0

CBS News/NY Times*

07/09 - 07/17

LV

24

43

Clinton +19.0

Gallup

07/12 - 07/15

483 A

25

34

Clinton +9.0

Rasmussen

07/09 - 07/15

1300 LV

25

38

Clinton +13.0

Zogby

07/12 - 07/14

396 LV

25

37

Clinton +12.0

American Res. Group

07/09 - 07/12

600 LV

25

38

Clinton +13.0

AP-Ipsos

07/09 - 07/11

Adults

20

36

Clinton +16.0

USA Today/Gallup

07/06 - 07/08

516 RV

21

37

Clinton +16.0

CBS News/NY Times*

06/26 - 06/28

336 LV

24

48

Clinton +24.0

Rasmussen

06/25 - 06/28

769 LV

26

39

Clinton +13.0

FOX News

06/26 - 06/27

RV

19

42

Clinton +23.0

CNN

06/22 - 06/24

450 RV

23

35

Clinton +12.0

Cook/RT Strategies

06/21 - 06/23

378 RV

22

32

Clinton +10.0

Newsweek

06/20 - 06/21

422 RV

27

43

Clinton +16.0

Rasmussen

06/18 - 06/21

763 LV

25

37

Clinton +12.0

Cook/RT Strategies

06/15 - 06/17

380 RV

20

30

Clinton +10.0

Rasmussen

06/11 - 06/14

775 LV

27

38

Clinton +11.0

USA Today/Gallup

06/11 - 06/14

1007 A

21

33

Clinton +12.0

American Res. Group

06/09 - 06/12

600 LV

19

39

Clinton +20.0

NBC/WSJ

06/08 - 06/11

Adults

25

39

Clinton +14.0

Quinnipiac

06/05 - 06/11

789 LV

21

35

Clinton +14.0

LA Times/Bloomberg

06/07 - 06/10

449 LV

22

33

Clinton +11.0

Rasmussen

06/04 - 06/07

773 LV

25

37

Clinton +12.0

FOX News

06/05 - 06/06

RV

23

36

Clinton +13.0

AP-Ipsos

06/04 - 06/06

541 LV

21

33

Clinton +12.0

USA Today/Gallup

06/01 - 06/03

470 LV

30

29

Obama +1.0

ABC News/Wash Post

05/29 - 06/01

1205 Adults

23

35

Clinton +12.0

Rasmussen

05/29 - 05/31

738 LV

26

34

Clinton +8.0

Rasmussen

05/21 - 05/23

559 LV

26

35

Clinton +9.0

NYT/CBS News*

05/18 - 05/23

441 LV

24

46

Clinton +22.0

Zogby

05/17 - 05/20

411 RV

24

39

Clinton +15.0

Hotline/FD

05/16 - 05/20

261 LV

21

31

Clinton +10.0

Rasmussen

05/14 - 05/17

788 LV

25

35

Clinton +10.0

FOX News

05/15 - 05/16

900 RV

20

35

Clinton +15.0

Cook/RT Strategies

05/11 - 05/13

402 RV

24

32

Clinton +8.0

Gallup

05/10 - 05/13

489 LV

26

35

Clinton +9.0

American Res. Group

05/09 - 05/12

600 LV

22

39

Clinton +17.0

Rasmussen

05/07 - 05/10

789 LV

33

35

Clinton +2.0

USA Today/Gallup

05/04 - 05/06

491 RV

23

38

Clinton +15.0

CNN/Opinion Research

05/04 - 05/06

454 RV

24

38

Clinton +14.0

Rasmussen

04/30 - 05/03

760 LV

26

34

Clinton +8.0

Marist

04/26 - 05/01

392 RV

17

35

Clinton +18.0

Quinnipiac

04/25 - 05/01

499 RV

18

32

Clinton +14.0

Cook/RT Strategies

04/27 - 04/30

389 RV

24

32

Clinton +8.0

Rasmussen

04/23 - 04/26

765 LV

32

30

Obama +2.0

NBC/WSJ

04/20 - 04/23

Adults

31

36

Clinton +5.0

Pew Research

04/18 - 04/22

574 RV

24

34

Clinton +10.0

Rasmussen

04/16 - 04/19

579 LV

32

32

Tie

FOX News

04/17 - 04/18

RV

20

41

Clinton +21.0

USA Today/Gallup

04/13 - 04/15

504 RV

26

31

Clinton +5.0

ABC News/Wash Post

04/12 - 04/15

Adults

20

37

Clinton +17.0

CNN

04/10 - 04/12

RV

26

30

Clinton +4.0

Rasmussen

04/09 - 04/12

774 LV

30

32

Clinton +2.0

CBS News*

04/09 - 04/12

392 RV

24

39

Clinton +15.0

American Res. Group

04/09 - 04/12

600 LV

24

36

Clinton +12.0

Time

04/05 - 04/09

493 RV

26

33

Clinton +7.0

LA Times/Bloomberg

04/05 - 04/09

557 RV

23

33

Clinton +10.0

Gallup

04/02 - 04/05

491 A

19

38

Clinton +19.0

Rasmussen

04/02 - 04/05

774 LV

29

34

Clinton +5.0

Cook/RT Strategies

03/29 - 04/01

355 RV

17

41

Clinton +24.0

Rasmussen

03/26 - 03/29

799 LV

26

33

Clinton +7.0

FOX News

03/27 - 03/28

RV

18

36

Clinton +18.0

Time

03/23 - 03/26

511 RV

24

31

Clinton +7.0

Zogby

03/22 - 03/26

432 LV

22

32

Clinton +10.0

USA Today/Gallup

03/23 - 03/25

493 A

22

35

Clinton +13.0

Pew Research

03/21 - 03/25

614 RV

26

35

Clinton +9.0

Rasmussen

03/19 - 03/22

757 LV

25

37

Clinton +12.0

Rasmussen

03/12 - 03/15

790 LV

30

35

Clinton +5.0

Time

03/09 - 03/12

682 RV

26

34

Clinton +8.0

CNN

03/09 - 03/11

447 RV

22

37

Clinton +15.0

Rasmussen

03/05 - 03/08

783 LV

26

38

Clinton +12.0

AP-Ipsos

03/05 - 03/07

RV

21

38

Clinton +17.0

American Res. Group

03/02 - 03/05

600 LV

31

34

Clinton +3.0

NBC/WSJ

03/02 - 03/05

Adults

28

40

Clinton +12.0

USA Today/Gallup

03/02 - 03/04

482 A

22

36

Clinton +14.0

Rasmussen

02/26 - 03/01

769 LV

26

34

Clinton +8.0

FOX News

02/27 - 02/28

RV

23

34

Clinton +11.0

Time

02/23 - 02/26

RV

24

36

Clinton +12.0

ABC News/Wash Post

02/22 - 02/25

Adults

24

36

Clinton +12.0

Zogby

02/22 - 02/24

LV

25

33

Clinton +8.0

Rasmussen

02/19 - 02/22

568 LV

26

37

Clinton +11.0

Quinnipiac

02/13 - 02/19

684 RV

23

38

Clinton +15.0

Cook/RT Strategies

02/15 - 02/18

390 RV

20

42

Clinton +22.0

Marist

02/12 - 02/15

471 RV

17

37

Clinton +20.0

USA Today/Gallup

02/09 - 02/11

495 A

21

40

Clinton +19.0

Siena

02/06 - 02/09

RV

12

45

Clinton +33.0

Rasmussen

02/05 - 02/08

435 LV

23

28

Clinton +5.0

Rasmussen

01/29 - 02/03

448 LV

18

34

Clinton +16.0

FOX News

01/30 - 01/31

RV

15

43

Clinton +28.0

Rasmussen

01/22 - 01/25

435 LV

19

33

Clinton +14.0

Time

01/22 - 01/23

480 RV

21

40

Clinton +19.0

CNN

01/19 - 01/21

467 RV

18

34

Clinton +16.0

ABC News/Wash Post

01/16 - 01/19

561 A

17

41

Clinton +24.0

Rasmussen

01/15 - 01/18

386 LV

24

31

Clinton +7.0

Gallup

01/12 - 01/14

1003 A

18

29

Clinton +11.0

Rasmussen

01/08 - 01/11

401 LV

21

22

Clinton +1.0

Zogby

01/05 - 01/09

339 LV

14

29

Clinton +15.0

Gallup

12/11 - 12/14

511 A

20

33

Clinton +13.0

NBC/WSJ

12/08 - 12/11

1006 A

18

37

Clinton +19.0

ABC News/Wash Post

12/07 - 12/11

1005 A

17

39

Clinton +22.0

CNN

12/05 - 12/07

612 RV

15

37

Clinton +22.0

FOX News

12/05 - 12/06

900 RV

12

33

Clinton +21.0

Marist

11/27 - 12/03

RV

12

33

Clinton +21.0

CNN

11/17 - 11/19

RV

15

33

Clinton +18.0

Gallup

11/09 - 11/12

A

19

31

Clinton +12.0

Pew Research

11/09 - 11/12

RV

23

39

Clinton +16.0

Cook/RT Strategies

11/09 - 11/12

RV

20

34

Clinton +14.0

McLaughlin & Associates (R)

11/07 - 11/07

LV

21

27

Clinton +6.0

CNN

10/27 - 10/29

RV

17

28

Clinton +11.0