08 April 2008

Stephen King, The New York Times, and Kulchur


As much as I love my Ulysses, my Bleak House, and my Eliot, I love my Stephen King. Indeed, I’ve a thing for the horror genre (oh, sure—I’ve probably got some dysfunctional psychological mechanism that prompts this taste, but what the hell). I’ve just finished King’s most recent novel, Duma Key, which was fine. It wasn’t overwhelming in characterization, in atmosphere, or in thrills, but it was King. I’m mighty fond of his plainspoken, intertextual, pop-culturally literate storytelling that focuses on quirky, but often quite normal folks. King reflects and recreates contemporary Americana much as Dickens did with Victoriana (and not the frilly, silly kind). Are his works “lowbrow”? At this time, many would say “yes.” In the future? Well, who knows how readers of 2042 will view King. Y’all know that Dickens was a pop culture writer, correct? And yes, the term “pop culture” is a fairly recent invention, as is the distinction between “high” and “low” culture (see Huyssen, After the Great Divide, for just one text that deals with the categorization of “high culture” and “mass culture” as a modern phenomenon). The latter point brings us back to Duma Key, and a response I’ve been itching to make for the past month.
The novel received an “iffy” review from James Campbell in a March 2nd New York Times book review. It was an average review (and I’d qualify the novel as “average.” Sorry SK. I did enjoy Lisey's Story though); Campbell neither damned nor celebrated the novel. What I found interesting, however, was Campbell’s discussion of the high/low divide, which essentially branded King, and other popular writers, as contributing little more to culture than commercial revenue.
In 2003, King was awarded with National Book Foundation’s Medal for Distinguished Contribution to American Letters. In his review, Campbell draws on King’s acceptance speech (in full here), specifically, King’s references to those who “‘make a point of pride’ of choosing not to read John Grisham, Clive Barker, or Mary Higgins Clark: ‘What do you think? You get social or academic brownie points for deliberately staying out of touch with your own culture?’” (King qtd. in Campbell). Campbell cites King’s reprimand to those who resist pop lit (several of whom, apparently, resisted the NBF’s decision to award King the medal). Fair enough. Unfortunately, Campbell then distorts and inverts King’s argument so that it becomes a sort of reverse-snobbery as he suggests that King supports a culture defined by commercial interests: “[l]eaving aside the discourtesy of suggesting that his listeners’ reading habits were directed by snobbery rather than taste, the remark posits a view of a culture based not on the best that is thought and said, but on the highest returns at the cash register” (Campbell). Firstly, King targets readers who “make [it] a point of pride” to reject popular fiction out of hand, not people who simply don’t enjoy it. I think it’s safe to say that the former type indeed practices cultural snobbery. Such behavior brings to mind some of my more smug acquaintances who assert “I never watch reality shows because they’re for the sheep. No one of any intellect would watch American Idol or Survivor [etc.].” I’m not saying that people should watch reality shows if they’re sincerely uninterested in them, but taking pride in the wholesale rejection of said shows speaks volumes about the insecurities of the person who must appear culturally superior (which smacks of the poseur).
Moreover, culture is more than Matthew Arnold’s definition of “the best that is thought or said”; culture is, if the Oxford English Dictionary is to be trusted, “The distinctive ideas, customs, social behaviour, products, or way of life of a particular society, people, or period. Hence: a society or group characterized by such customs, etc.” This prosaic, rather than romantic or idealistic, definition is inclusive and involves all members of society as they both consume and contribute to culture, be it the jazz connoisseurs or the hip-hoppers, the opera supporters or the Celine Dion fans (okay—maybe that’s stretching it, but you get the point), the Stephen Kings or the William Faulkners.
Despite complaining about King’s complaints, Campbell narrows his argument by returning his focus to Duma Key. However, he tries to have it two ways in qualifying the novel’s cultural status: first, he attempts to measure Duma Key against a definition of “literary fiction”—a standard that the novel fails to meet (and a criteria King has never claimed of his work). After Campbell negates the novel’s “literary” value, he judges the book on its merits as pop fiction by noting (in a modification of a Wildean epigram) that “there is no such thing as popular or literary fiction. ‘Books are well written or badly written. That is all.’” And while this remark might target Duma Key, questioning its status as “well written,” which is fair, this concluding statement’s generosity in resisting a divide between “literary” and “popular” rings false, for Campbell has, indeed, re-inscribed the difference between “literary” and “popular” fiction, explicitly and implicitly, several times in the body of his review.
King doesn’t claim to write great literature; the man consistently refers to himself as a storyteller. It’s interesting that others insist on making the distinction between “high art” and King’s craft as though he’s presuming to be an artiste and intruding on “proper writers’” literary space. Ah, well. So goes the neverending kulchur war. Cheers, Mr. “sweetness and light,” you old tastemaker you.

Update, 09 April: I've just discovered a review of Campbell's review over at The Seated View. It's a treat.

11 March 2008

On Seltzer--Again

According to Inga Muscio, a friend of Margaret Seltzer’s (and who only discovered Seltzer’s deception when ‘phoned by an agent, Faye Bender, who worked for both Muscio and Seltzer), Seltzer has collected government cheques on the basis of her Native American “ancestry.”

Seltzer managed a long-term masquerade, and she took numerous people in. Among them, Ms. Muscio, Ms. Bender, and Seltzer’s ethnic studies professor. Are these people somehow at fault for believing what appears to have been a well-researched, well-presented character role? No. Ms. Muscio and Ms. Bender have resisted defending Seltzer’s actions, but the good professor’s apologia, however sympathetic and well-intended, backfires in several ways. In my estimation, the most significant is the patronizing element in excusing a white woman’s “giving voice” to a community that Seltzer (and the professor) characterize as “silenced.”

The professor is a kind and generous person. I’m unsurprised that he lent support to a former student undergoing so public an excoriation; however, I am surprised at his means of offering said support.

10 March 2008

"Plagiarizing Other People's Trauma" ?

A middle class white female, Margaret Seltzer (a.k.a. Margaret B. Jones), was raised in a California suburb. She attended an Episcopalian school, and went on to spend some time at the University of Oregon. At some point, she decided to assume a new identity. She claimed Native American ancestry, that she grew up in South Central L. A., that she was passed from foster family to foster family, that she was a drug-runner for a notorious gang, and so on. Then Seltzer publishes her “experiences” as Love and Consequences.

This last week, Seltzer’s sister revealed that the story is fraudulent. Seltzer concocted everything she related as lived experience; she even made up an anti-gang foundation that she claims to be associated with (and publicized on the book’s jacket). And no, she did not graduate from the University of Oregon with a degree in Ethnic Studies.

People are outraged--but for differing reasons. I offer two opinion pieces of the work (there are hundreds available, of course--see Google--but I found these intriguing):

“Stolen Suffering," by Daniel Mendelsohn at The New York Times, argues that Seltzer has appropriated people’s pain for psychological and financial benefit (this blog post's title comes from Mendelsohn's article).

“Fine Line Separates Memoir, Novel” by Gordon Sayre, at The Register-Guard (Eugene, OR), argues that what matters is whether the work is well-researched, that Selzter communicates on behalf of excluded voices, and that we might consider why we want to read about other people’s pain.

So then, is it only a matter of marketing here? Or has Seltzer done more than misfire in presenting Love and Consequences as an autobiography? Has she committed some great intellectual, social, or cultural sin? Is authenticity important?
More on this later.